The Decision: Roth or Traditional IRA?

We’ve talked about making the call between a 401k vs a Roth IRA retirement account, but what if we add an extra decision to your plate by telling you that you can also choose between a Roth or traditional IRA?

Don’t panic!

We’re throwing more information at you, yes, but an informed girl is a savvy girl and that’s the goal here. 

Instead of letting you get overwhelmed by choice, we’re giving you the deets about allllll of your options so that you can make an educated decision.

We know — we rock.

Once Again, It All Comes Down to Taxes

We’ve said it before and we’ll say it again: most of your big financial decisions come down to when you pay taxes

There’s no way to avoid taxes forever, but you do get to choose when you pay them.

We’ll take what we can get, I guess.

The biggest difference between a Roth or traditional IRA is when you get to take advantage of your tax break. 

Contributions to traditional IRAs are tax-deductible, but you’ll pay taxes later when you make withdrawals.

On the flip side of that situation, you’ll pay taxes on your contributions to a Roth IRA, but your withdrawals during retirement (you know, when you actually need the money) are tax-free.

Unless you are clairvoyant, it’s impossible to know what your tax rate will be in the future.

But, you know what is possible to know? The current tax rate. And, right now, tax rates are historically low. 

That’s why we believe there’s a clear winner here in the form of the Roth IRA.

Why play tax roulette by deferring taxes until retirement when your rate is much less certain?

You have a defined tax rate right now and no way to know what your tax rate will be in the future, so get the taxes part out of the way now.

This will allow you to maximize your available income during retirement.

If you’re still unsure, there are a few other factors to consider that can help make your decision.

Rules, Rules, Rules


Let’s talk about withdrawals first. AKA, actually GETTING your money!

Although early withdrawals are generally frowned upon, you’ve got much more flexibility with a Roth than a traditional.

A Roth IRA allows you to withdraw contributions (the money you put into the account, not the earnings) without having to pay income taxes or an early withdrawal penalty.             

If you try to do the same with a traditional IRA, you’re likely to pay a 10% penalty and owe taxes at your current rate on the money you take out. 

Required Minimum Distributions

Next, RMDs.

If you’ve forgotten or you’re new here (greetings!!!), a required minimum distribution is a way for the government to MAKE you start using your retirement money. 

Traditional IRAs require you to start taking out minimum distributions at age 73.

Can you believe??

You make it all the way to retirement, saving money along the way like the badass you are, and then the government has the audacity to tell you when and how you use it.

Um, no thanks.

With a Roth IRA, you’re free to let those savings stay put and continue to grow (tax-free, baby!) as long as you live.

This is yet another A+ in our book, as this makes the Roth IRA a great way to pass money on to your beneficiaries, if you so choose.

Income Requirements

Finally, it’s important to talk about who is eligible for each type of retirement plan based on income.

Absolutely anyone with earned income can contribute to a traditional IRA. 

Roth IRAs, on the other hand, have income-eligibility restrictions.

So, if you’re a high earner, you might be exempt from contributing to a Roth IRA. 

If that’s the case, great! Your decision has been made for you.

The Bottom Line 

In short, Traditional IRAs function a little like a pension — in return for tax breaks, you are susceptible to certain restrictions and the government has a say in how and when you access your funds.

A Roth IRA functions more like an investment account with tax benefits — you still get a tax break but with fewer restrictions and more flexibility.

The choice is up to you, but we believe the Roth IRA offers a lot more freedom of choice, while also allowing you to plan ahead. 

If we’ve done such a good job convincing you that you’re regretting your choice of a Traditional IRA… we have good news. In most cases you can convert a traditional IRA to a Roth, allowing you to take further control of your retirement plan without losing your progress so far.

Additionally, some companies now offer a Roth 401k, making your life that much easier! Ask Nancy in HR about your company’s specific offerings to get started!

No matter what, you deserve to be in complete control of your financial future.

Choosing a plan that will maximize your retirement income ensures that your hard work now pays off in the form of a carefree retirement later.

Roth or Traditional IRA FAQs

Which is better a traditional or Roth IRA?

It’s like asking whether cake or ice cream is better – it depends on your taste! In the world of IRAs, your preference would depend on your tax situation and when you want to pay those pesky taxes. Traditional IRA contributions are tax-deductible now, but Uncle Sam gets his share when you withdraw. With Roth IRAs, you pay taxes upfront, but withdrawals in retirement are tax-free. Yay!

What are the disadvantages of a Roth IRA?

Well, every rose has its thorns, right? With a Roth IRA, you get no immediate tax break, and there are income limits to contribute. Plus, you have to wait five tax years to withdraw earnings tax-free even if you are 59 1/2. It’s like waiting for your favorite band to release their new album!

Why choose a Roth IRA over traditional?

Think of it like booking a vacation. You could pay now (Roth), enjoy your trip, and not worry about the bill when you get home. You get tax-free growth and withdrawals, plus there are no required minimum distributions. It’s like the holiday that keeps on giving!

Do you pay more taxes on a Roth or traditional IRA?

That’s a bit like asking if you’d rather stub your toe now or later. With a Roth, you pay taxes upfront when your money goes in. With a traditional IRA, you defer taxes until you withdraw in retirement. So, it really depends on whether you think your tax rate will be higher now or in your golden years.

Why don’t people use Roth IRA?

That’s like asking why some people don’t like pineapple on pizza; everyone’s situation and preferences are different! Some higher earners simply make too much to contribute. Others may anticipate lower tax rates in retirement and prefer the upfront deduction they get with a traditional IRA. Also, not everyone enjoys paying their tax bill before it’s absolutely necessary!

Discover the Secrets to Creating a Secure Retirement Income Portfolio in Just 17 Minutes!

Since 2018, we've empowered over 200 women to take control of their retirement futures. Our proven approach has transformed lives, and we're confident it can do the same for you. It's simpler and quicker than you ever imagined. Ready to take the first step?

Unlock immediate access to our exclusive 17-minute video case study and witness our successful system in action. After watching, complete a brief questionnaire to help us craft a personalized retirement plan tailored to your needs. If it resonates with you, we'll partner up to bring your dream retirement to life. Don't wait – your future self will thank you!

Leave a Comment